Three-dimensional canine displacement patterns in response to translation and controlled tipping retraction strategies.

OBJECTIVE: To validate whether applying a well-defined initial three-dimensional (3D) load can create consistently expected tooth movement in patients. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-one patients who needed bilateral canine retraction to close extraction space were selected for this split-mouth clinical trial. After initial alignment and leveling, two canines in each patient were randomly assigned to receive either translation (TR) or controlled tipping (CT) load. The load was delivered by segmental T-loops designed to give specific initial moment/force ratios to the canines in each treatment interval (TI), verified with an orthodontic force tester. Maxillary dental casts were made before canine retraction and after each TI. The casts were digitized with a 3D laser scanner. The digital models were superimposed on the palatal rugae region. The 3D canine displacements and the displacement patterns in terms of TR, CT, and torque were calculated for each TI. RESULTS: The method can reliably detect a TR displacement greater than 0.3 mm and a rotation greater than 1.5 degrees . Ninety-two TIs had displacements that were greater than 0.3 mm and were used for further analysis. Most displacements were oriented within +/-45 degrees from the distal direction. The displacement pattern in terms of TR or CT was not uniquely controlled by the initial moment/force ratio. CONCLUSIONS: The initial load system is not the only key factor controlling tooth movement. Using a segmental T-loop with a well-controlled load system, large variations in canine displacement can be expected clinically.